Super telephoto zooms
Whether you’re shooting birds in the garden or big game in the wild, you’ll need long telephoto reach.
There are plenty of exotic prime lenses out there that can cost a small fortune. There’s no question that these monster lenses perform extremely well, but their hefty price tag means there out of reach for most of us.
Manufacturers though are also fully aware of this, with a growing number of extreme telephoto lenses now available for the photographer who wants to get close to the action, but doesn’t want to re-mortgage the house to do so.
With competing lenses starting at £740/$ 1,000 and giving extravagant reach of up to 600mm (900mm on an APS-C sensor DSLR), there are plenty of options to choose from.
There are some appealing own-brand Canon and Nikon lenses to choose from, but they face stiff competition from the likes of Sigma and Tamron, especially when it comes to telephoto reach. Let’s go wild!
1. Sigma 150-600mm f/5-6.3 DG OS HSM | S
It’s a ‘sport’ lens by name and nature
Lens mount: Canon EF, Nikon FX, Sigma SA | Maximum aperture: f/5-6.3 | Minimum aperture: f/22 | Lens construction: 24 elements in 16 groups | Minimum focus distance: 2.6m | Optical stabiliser: 4 stops | Filter size: 105mm | Weight: 2,860g
Sigma 150-600mm f/5-6.3 DG OS HSM | S
The Sigma 150-600mm Sport boasts two top-grade FLD (Fluorite Low Dispersion) elements, but the optical design means it tips the scales at almost 3kg. It therefore feels rather substantial, and comes with a carrying strap that attaches to lugs on the lens barrel. A bonus for rainy-day shooting is that, unlike the C version of the lens (see below), this one features a full set of weather-seals instead of just a sealed mount. All fit options include a highly effective, dual-mode stabiliser for static and panning shots. The autofocus system is noticeably faster than in the other Sigma and Tamron 150-600mm lenses on test, while retaining much better sharpness at the long end of its zoom range.
2. Nikon AF-S 200-500mm f/5.6E ED VR
Big reach at an affordable price
Lens mount: Nikon FX | Maximum aperture: f/5.6 | Minimum aperture: f/32 | Lens construction: 19 elements in 12 groups | Minimum focus distance: 2.2m | Optical stabiliser: 4.5 stops | Filter size: 95mm | Weight: 1,970g
Nikon AF-S 200-500mm f/5.6E ED VR
For a Nikon lens, the 200-500mm is competitively priced, although it’s still rather more than the Sigma C-line and Tamron 150-600mm lenses. Even so, it’s less than two thirds of the price of the Nikon 80-400mm, while boasting some updated features, including an improved VR system that’s rated at 4.5 stops and a ‘sport’ mode. This applies to stabilisation only during actual exposures, making it easier to track erratically moving wildlife through the viewfinder. It has an electromagnetically controlled diaphragm for more consistent continuous shooting, while AF is performs well. Sharpness is on a par with the 80-400mm right up to the 400mm setting, and only drops off a little at 500mm. The lens doesn’t feature Nikon’s Nano Crystal Coat, but resistance to ghosting and flare is still good.
3. Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS
A Canon zoom with a new twist
Lens mount: Canon EF | Maximum aperture: f/4.5-5.6 | Minimum aperture: f/32-40 | Lens construction: 21 elements in 16 groups | Minimum focus distance: 0.98m | Optical stabiliser: 4 stops | Filter size: 77mm | Weight: 1,640g
Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS
Top-quality glass includes fluorite and Super UD elements to boost sharpness and contrast and reduce chromatic aberrations, along with Canon’s ASC (Air Sphere Coating) to tackle ghosting and flare. There’s also an updated four-stop stabiliser with three operating modes. Fast autofocusing is pretty much the same as in Canon’s 70-300mm lens, and there’s nothing to choose in levels of sharpness and contrast at equal zoom settings. However, sharpness from the 100-400mm drops off at the long end, and it’s more expensive.
4. Sigma 150-600mm f/5-6.3 DG OS HSM | C
It’s feature-rich but low in price
Lens mount: Canon EF, Nikon FX, Sigma SA | Maximum aperture: f/5-6.3 | Minimum aperture: f/22 | Lens construction: 20 elements in 14 groups | Minimum focus distance: 2.8m | Optical stabiliser: 4 stops | Filter size: 95mm | Weight: 1,930g
Sigma 150-600mm f/5-6.3 DG OS HSM | C
Despite being one of the most affordable lenses here, it has a comparatively high-end set of features. There’s a dual-mode autofocus system that can give priority to auto or manual focusing. To avoid zoom creep, you can engage the zoom lock switch at any position that has a marked focal length on the zoom ring. Build quality feels good; although the lens isn’t fully weather-sealed, it does have a rubber sealing ring on the mount. The speed of autofocusing is pretty quick and as is often the case, sharpness drops off at the long end of the zoom range, but less noticeably than in the Tamron lens.
5. Canon EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6L IS USM
Not your average 70-300mm
Lens mount: Canon EF | Maximum aperture: f/4-5.6 | Minimum aperture: f/32-45 | Lens construction: 16 elements in 11 groups | Minimum focus distance: 1.2m | Optical stabiliser: 4 stops | Filter size: 67mm | Weight: 1,050g
Canon EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6L IS USM
Most 70-300mm lenses have a ‘budget’ feel to them, but not this L-series (Luxury) lens from Canon. It features two UD (Ultra-low Dispersion) elements, plus a four-stop image stabiliser with a switchable panning mode. Typical L-series telephoto trappings include comprehensive weather-seals and an off-white finish to reduce heat build-up. In keeping with its relatively short maximum focal length, this is the lightest lens in the group at just over a kilogram. Autofocus is fast and accurate, while sharpness and contrast are excellent throughout the entire zoom range. However, for wildlife photography, this full-frame compatible lens is better suited to an APS-C format body, where it has an effective maximum reach of 480mm.
6. Tamron SP 150-600mm f/5-6.3 Di VC USD
Light, simple and affordable
Lens mount: Canon EF, Nikon FX, Sony A | Maximum aperture: f/5-6.3 | Minimum aperture: f/32 | Lens construction: 20 elements in 13 groups | Minimum focus distance: 2.7m | Optical stabiliser: 4 stops | Filter size: 95mm | Weight: 1,951g
Tamron SP 150-600mm f/5-6.3 Di VC USD
The Tamron gives the same enormous telephoto reach as the Sigma C-line lens, in a similarly compact and lightweight package. The Tamron feels well put together and, unlike the Nikon and Sigma counterparts, features a full set of weather seals. Controls are fairly basic, with only a single autofocus mode that gives the usual full-time manual override from its ring-type ultrasonic system. Similarly, VC (Vibration Compensation) has no dedicated panning mode: Tamron claims that its system is effective for both static and panning shots. Performance is good in most respects, with quick autofocus. Sharpness is good across most of the zoom range – but drops off more at the long end than with any of the other lenses on test.
7. Nikon AF-S 80-400mm f/4.5-5.6G ED VR
A major upgrade from the original
Lens mount: Nikon FX | Maximum aperture: f/4.5-5.6 | Minimum aperture: f/32-40 | Lens construction: 20 elements in 12 groups | Minimum focus distance: 1.5m | Optical stabiliser: 4 stops | Filter size: 77mm | Weight: 1,570g
Nikon AF-S 80-400mm f/4.5-5.6G ED VR
This new AF-S version features fast and near-silent ring-type ultrasonic autofocus, and an updated stabiliser that gives a four-stop advantage. Even so, the stabiliser isn’t quite as effective as that of the Nikon 200-500mm lens on test, and lacks the latter’s ‘sport’ mode. Optical highlights include four ED (Extra-low Dispersion) elements plus a Super ED element. The lens lacks the Canon 80-400mm’s weather-seals, but has a sealed mounting plate. Performance is impressive but, considering it’s the most expensive lens in the group, it’s a shame some of Nikon’s latest developments are lacking, like an electromagnetically controlled diaphragm to improve rapid-fire continuous shooting.
8. Sigma APO 50-500mm f/4.5-6.3 DG OS HSM
Superzoom meets super-telephoto
Lens mount: Canon EF, Nikon FX, Pentax K, Sigma SA, Sony A | Maximum aperture: f/4.5-6.3 | Minimum aperture: f/22 | Lens construction: 22 elements in 16 groups | Minimum focus distance: 0.5-1.8m | Optical stabiliser: 4 stops | Filter size: 95mm | Weight: 1,970g
Sigma APO 50-500mm f/4.5-6.3 DG OS HSM
Most telephoto zoom lenses have a 4x zoom range or thereabouts, but this Sigma is more like a superzoom lens, with a huge 10x zoom range. A little unusually, the stabiliser is fitted in all mount options. For cameras that feature a sensor-shift stabiliser, you get the choice of whether to use in-camera or in-lens stabilisation. Quality glass includes four SLD (Special Low Dispersion) elements. The lens’ ring-type ultrasonic autofocus system is fairly rapid but not super-fast. Edge-sharpness is a little lacking at both ends of the zoom range, but centre-sharpness is very good on the whole, only really dropping off in the 400-500mm sector.
This feature was originally published in Digital Camera Magazine, to subscribe, click here